Shearman & Sterling LLP multinational law firm headquartered in New York City, United States.

balance scale

Apr 14, 2016

Eighth Circuit Holds Presumption of Reliance Rebutted Under Halliburton II and Reverses Class Certification in Securities Action

Subscribe

Jump to...

 
On April 12, 2016, in IBEW Local 98 Pension Fund v. Best Buy Co., No. 14-3178, slip. op. (8th Cir. Apr. 12, 2016), the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit became the first Court of Appeals to hold that a defendant had rebutted Basic’s presumption of reliance by showing lack of price impact pursuant to the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Halliburton II.   More specifically, the Best Buy court rejected Plaintiffs’ contention that alleged misrepresentations had artificially maintained stock prices, even though Plaintiffs alleged a subsequent corrective disclosure had led to a significant stock-price decline.  The decision makes clear that lack of price impact remains a significant avenue of attack in the class certification context – at least in the Eighth Circuit, and with the right set of facts.

View full memo, Eighth Circuit Holds Presumption of Reliance Rebutted Under Halliburton II and Reverses Class Certification in Securities Action

Authors and Contributors

Stuart J. Baskin

Partner

Litigation

+1 212 848 4974

+1 212 848 4974

New York

Matthew L. Craner

Partner

Litigation

+1 212 848 5255

+1 212 848 5255

New York

Agnès Dunogué

Partner

Litigation

+1 212 848 5257

+1 212 848 5257

New York

H. Miriam Farber

Knowledge Management Attorney

Litigation

+1 212 848 5156

+1 212 848 5156

New York

Stephen Fishbein

Partner

Litigation

+1 212 848 4424

+1 212 848 4424

New York

Jerome S. Fortinsky

Partner

Litigation

+1 212 848 4900

+1 212 848 4900

New York

Alan S. Goudiss

Partner

Litigation

+1 212 848 4906

+1 212 848 4906

New York

John Gueli

Partner

Litigation

+1 212 848 4744

+1 212 848 4744

New York

Adam Hakki

Partner

Litigation

+1 212 848 4924

+1 212 848 4924

New York

Daniel H.R. Laguardia

Partner

Litigation

+1 415 616 1114

+1 415 616 1114

+1 212 848 4731

+1 212 848 4731

San Francisco

Christopher L. LaVigne

Partner

Litigation

+1 212 848 4432

+1 212 848 4432

New York

Daniel Lewis

Partner

Litigation

+1 212 848 8691

+1 212 848 8691

New York

John A. Nathanson

Partner

Litigation

+1 212 848 8611

+1 212 848 8611

New York

Brian H. Polovoy

Partner

Litigation

+1 212 848 4703

+1 212 848 4703

New York

Jeffrey J. Resetarits

Partner

Litigation

+1 212 848 7116

+1 212 848 7116

New York

William J. F. Roll, III

General Counsel

Litigation

+1 212 848 4260

+1 212 848 4260

New York

Richard F. Schwed

Partner

Litigation

+1 212 848 5445

+1 212 848 5445

New York

Patrick D. Robbins

Partner

Litigation

+1 415 616 1210

+1 415 616 1210

San Francisco

Mark D. Lanpher

Partner

Litigation

+1 202 508 8120

+1 202 508 8120

Washington DC

Brian G. Burke

Partner

Litigation

+1 212 848 7140

+1 212 848 7140

+86 21 6136 5000

+86 21 6136 5000

New York

Practices