Shearman Logo

balance scale

Dec 04, 2015

Delaware Supreme Court Decision in Rural/Metro Affirms $76 million Judgment Against Third-Party Advisor for Aiding and Abetting Breaches of Fiduciary Duty by Board, but Rejects Suggestion of ‘Gatekeeper’ Duties

Subscribe

Jump to...

 

On November 30, 2015, the Delaware Supreme Court affirmed post-trial decisions by the Delaware Court of Chancery (i) holding RBC Capital Markets, LLC liable to Rural/Metro Corp. shareholders for nearly $76 million based upon a finding that RBC had aided and abetted the Rural/Metro board of directors’ breach of fiduciary duty by manipulating Rural/Metro’s 2011 sale process, and (ii) limiting the parties from whom RBC could claim settlement contribution to those who had been adjudicated joint tortfeasors based on the record at trial – a group that was held to exclude director defendants who would have qualified for exculpation from money liability under the corporation’s certificate of incorporation.  RBC Capital Markets, LLC v. Jervis (“Rural/Metro”), No. 140, 2015, 2015 WL 7721882 (Del. Nov. 30, 2015).  This ruling represents the first time Delaware’s highest court has held a financial advisor liable to shareholders for aiding and abetting a corporate board’s breach of the duty of care, continuing its recent string of rulings applying closer scrutiny to investment banker conflicts.  It also confirms that the protections afforded to director defendants under § 102(b)(7) can in some circumstances operate to increase the damages imposed against other defendants who do not qualify for exculpation.  Encouragingly, however, the Court’s decision expressly disavowed the lower court’s suggestion that financial advisors were “gatekeepers” with an obligation to affirmatively prevent fiduciaries from breaching their duties of care to constituents.

View full memo, Delaware Supreme Court Decision in Rural/Metro Affirms $76 million Judgment Against Third-Party Advisor for Aiding and Abetting Breaches of Fiduciary Duty by Board, but Rejects Suggestion of ‘Gatekeeper’ Duties

Authors and Contributors

Paula Howell Anderson

Partner

Litigation

+1 212 848 7727

+1 212 848 7727

New York

George Casey

Partner

Mergers & Acquisitions

+1 212 848 8787

+1 212 848 8787

New York

Alan S. Goudiss

Partner

Litigation

+1 212 848 4906

+1 212 848 4906

New York

Adam Hakki

Partner

Litigation

+1 212 848 4924

+1 212 848 4924

New York

Robert Katz

Partner

Mergers & Acquisitions

+1 212 848 8008

+1 212 848 8008

New York

Robert Masella

Partner

Mergers & Acquisitions

+1 212 848 5125

+1 212 848 5125

New York

John Marzulli

Partner

Mergers & Acquisitions

+1 212 848 8590

+1 212 848 8590

New York

Practices